In marketing and sales, not every lead will convert, and many will inevitably go cold. But a thoughtful, well-planned strategy can help you re-engage these prospects, reignite their interest, and build valuable connections—all while boosting your sales pipeline.
In this blog, we’ll look at practical, proven email tactics to help you bring cold prospects back into your funnel. From crafting personalized messages to offering relevant resources, we’ll explore how to turn lost opportunities into valuable conversions.
Understanding Leads Went Cold
A "cold lead" is a term for someone who used to be interested in your product or service but is no longer. They might have visited your website, signed up for newsletters, or interacted with your social media. However, for whatever reason, they stopped engaging.
These cold leads are valuable. They have shown interest in what you offer.
In theory, reaching out to these leads should take less effort than contacting new customers. They already know something about your business. Recognizing the difference in approach leads gone cold vs new leads is vital for devising an effective re-engagement strategy that reignites interest and boosts conversion rates.
Steps to Re-Engage a Prospect with Email
Step 1: Initiate Outreach with a Personalized Strategy
Effective re-engagement with a prospect starts with outreach. Your approach should be well-planned and deliberate.
Here’s how to make your outreach impactful:
Research Your Prospect: Look into their industry, job role, and challenges. Review their company’s website, LinkedIn page, and social media to uncover insights. This helps you to craft messaging that resonates with their needs and interests.
Include valuable Content: Focus on sharing content that addresses specific problems or interests. This can include blog posts, case studies, or whitepapers. Such content grabs attention and demonstrates expertise.
Personalize Your Message: Personalization is key. Use the lead’s name and reference relevant details to show your outreach is intentional. When you tailor messages to the specific recipient, you make the lead feel understood and valued.
AI can help streamline this effort. Here is a prompt that will build you an actionable table to get you started with value-driven, personalized messages, segmented by persona.
PROMPT: “I am trying to re-engage prospects and leads that have gone cold and my company sells {insert company url}, create a table: put my target personas in column a, KPIs they care about in column b, challenges they face in column c, job to be done in column d, email subject lines in column e, re-engagement hooks in column f, short message in column g, value content offer in column h, call to action in column i”
Sample results:
Step 2: Augment Email with Other Outreach Methods
Email is the preferred channel for re-engagement since 80% of buyers indicate they appreciate initial contact via email. And while email is effective, combining it with other outreach methods can enhance your efforts. Depending on resources and goals, consider cold calling or LinkedIn InMail as supplementary methods.
Here’s a breakdown to help you decide:
Evaluate Your Needs and Resources:
Cold calling can create faster and more personal connections. This is especially true in industries that prefer direct contact.
LinkedIn InMail provides a focused, professional way to connect with leads. It helps you reach them directly on a platform where they network actively.
Execute Thoughtfully: For cold calls, focus on concise and engaging communication. When using LinkedIn InMail, keep your message brief, relevant, and personable, respecting the professional setting of the platform.
Track Your Results: Tracking is essential for all outreach methods to measure engagement and success. Use link tracking in emails and check LinkedIn InMail response rates. This helps you see what connects with your audience.
Best Practices for Re-Engagement Emails
Adopting best practices can boost the effectiveness of your outreach and increase conversion rates:
Lead with Value: Begin each outreach with something valuable to the lead—such as advice, insights, or a free resource.
Provide Different Formats: Meet different preferences by offering resources in various formats, like videos, articles, and webinars. This helps engage leads based on how they like to learn.
Be Accessible: Ensure leads can easily reach someone on your team for questions or to schedule meetings. This builds trust and prevents them from seeking solutions elsewhere.
Establish Authority: Show that you are an expert in your field. Share insights, case studies, and knowledge that highlight your skills.
Step 3: Qualify Prospects Quickly
Qualifying prospects ensures that you allocate time and resources efficiently. By asking smart questions, you can assess how likely it is that a lead might convert. This helps you focus on the best prospects.
Here’s an approach:
Ask Specific Questions: If you sell a product for a certain industry, look for clues that a company has similar needs.
For example, if you sell industrial equipment, look for processes or tools that indicate your product might be helpful. A tailored question like, “Do you ever encounter [common industry problem]?” can help determine if the lead is a good fit.
Move On When Necessary: If a lead isn’t a match, it’s okay to disengage. Focus instead on qualified prospects who are more likely to benefit from your offering.
Avoiding Common Mistakes
Several common mistakes can derail lead-nurturing efforts. Here are pitfalls to avoid:
Don’t Move Too Quickly: Leads are cautious and may shy away if they feel rushed into making a decision. Build relationships at a natural pace rather than focusing solely on immediate conversion.
Provide Opt-Out Options: While it may seem counterproductive, allowing leads to opt out of communications can actually improve engagement with those who remain. It keeps your database clean and focused on high-quality prospects.
Maintain Accurate Link Tracking: Link tracking is useful, but it can negatively impact email deliverability. Use tracking selectively and avoid spammy practices, focusing on quality calls to action instead.
Key Takeaways for Re-Engaging a Prospect with Email
Personalize Outreach: Tailored approaches are more likely to resonate and increase response rates.
Qualify Leads Quickly: Efficiently qualify leads to focus on high-potential prospects.
Use Flexible Tactics: Use cold calls and emails according to your business needs, and continually test and track engagement.
Engage with Value: Always lead with value and provide options for multiple communication formats.
With these strategies in place, re-engaging cold leads becomes a strategic and successful endeavor. By understanding and implementing personalized outreach, consistent follow-ups, and proactive qualifications, businesses can transform cold leads into valuable, long-term customers.
Interested in learning more? Sign up for our newsletter.
Next in the series: How to Automate Lead Handling for Maximum Efficiency and Conversions
Comments